Polly | Orthopedic Handmade Loafers

Regular price $159.95 Sale price$69.95 Save 56%
/

UPS

Free Shipping with UPS

30-Day Money-Back Guarantee

A Chatham shop since 1994

Color
Size
Only a few left in stock!
Apple Pay Google Pay PayPal American Express Visa Mastercard Maestro Shop Pay
Ships by —
Free Shipping

FALL SALE UPDATE:

Eleanor buys in small runs for one shop, so only a limited number of these are left. If you can still click 'Add to cart', it's still available.

Handcrafted quality, orthopedic comfort. Perfect for everyday wear

The Polly Loafers combine artisanal craftsmanship with the soft, supportive comfort your feet need throughout the day. The premium leather-finish upper with subtle croco embossing gives a refined, timeless look — elegant without ever feeling too bold. Each pair is carefully handmade for durability and lasting quality.

Why women love the Polly Loafers

• Orthopedic-inspired support — cushioned footbed for pressure relief
• Handcrafted quality — durable, refined, and made to last
• Soft, breathable lining — keeps feet fresh all day
• Flexible, lightweight sole — supports balance & natural movement
• Refined croco embossing — elegant, subtle, never overpowering
• Everyday styling — perfect with trousers, jeans or simple dresses

A supportive, handcrafted loafer designed to bring comfort, stability and timeless style to every step.

Every order is packed by hand in Chatham and shipped free of charge anywhere in the United States. We use the reliable delivery services of UPS, and you'll hear from us the moment your parcel is on its way.

Thirty-two years of dressing women in Chatham, and the same promise online as in the shop. If a piece isn't right for you, send it back within 30 days and we'll refund you. No questions, no hurry.

We offer a range of secure and convenient payment methods to make your shopping experience seamless. Here's what we currently accept:

  • Credit or Debit Cards: all major cards, including Visa, Mastercard, and American Express.
  • Mobile Payment Services: Apple Pay, Shop Pay, or Google Pay for a quick and easy checkout.
  • Gift Cards or Store Credit: have a gift card or store credit from us? You can use it towards your purchase.
One Shop on Main Street, Since 1994

For thirty-two years this has been a small shop in Chatham, full of pieces meant to be worn, not admired on a hanger.

We were open from May to October and closed our doors every November, like most of the street. Women found us on a summer weekend, went home, and called the shop in the fall to ask if we still had that coat. We were closed.

My daughter Caroline spent eight years telling me we should be online. Last spring she won, on one condition: I keep choosing every piece myself. Twice a year, by hand, and never more than one shop can carry.

This is our first fall with the doors open. Thank you for being here for it.

Free shipping on every order

Shipped free across the U.S.

Secure checkout

Your payment is protected with industry-standard security

Thoughtful materials

Eco-Friendly & made with care

Easy returns

Shop with confidence. Return or exchange within 30 days, no questions.